Review by Jon Donnis
Musicals are not usually my preferred choice of entertainment, particularly when they run beyond the two-hour mark. However, Drummer Boy proved to be a rather pleasant surprise. Set against the backdrop of the American Revolution, this historical musical drama blends family conflict, romance, faith and the fight for freedom, delivering an unexpectedly enjoyable experience with several memorable musical moments.
Directed by Ben and Joel David Smallbone, the film follows brothers Benjamin and Jeremiah Clem, whose relationship is tested as the American colonies move towards independence. While Benjamin sympathises with the rebellion and joins the Continental Army, Jeremiah sides with the British Crown, placing the brothers on opposing sides of a conflict that threatens to tear their family apart.
Alongside their story is Emmalin, an enslaved woman determined to secure her freedom, and Elizabeth Balfour, whose relationship with Jeremiah becomes increasingly complicated. When Elizabeth fails to respond to Jeremiah's letters, Emmalin secretly takes her place, beginning a correspondence that gradually develops into something much deeper. It is an interesting subplot that adds romance and emotional complexity to an already busy story.
There is certainly plenty happening, perhaps too much at times. The film occasionally struggles to balance its historical drama with its musical ambitions, and some developments feel contrived rather than naturally earned. The wider historical circumstances surrounding the Revolution are also handled rather simplistically, leaving little room for the political and social complexities of the period. There are moments when the story feels more like a contemporary country-pop musical dressed in historical clothing than a convincing period drama. Some of the modern hairstyles and make-up choices don't help matters either.
Fortunately, the committed performances make it considerably easier to overlook these shortcomings.
Joel David Smallbone is particularly effective as Jeremiah, bringing personality and vulnerability to a character caught between family loyalty, personal ambition and his growing doubts about the cause he is fighting for. Lucas Leach is equally impressive as Benjamin, delivering a likeable performance that combines determination with vulnerability. His character's leg injury initially appears to be an obstacle to military service, but his musical ability eventually earns him a place within the Continental Army.
One of the film's strongest elements is the relationship between Benjamin and Major John Ambrose, played by Iain Glen. Their interactions provide some of the most sincere and affecting moments, with Glen bringing considerable warmth and authority to the role. The connection feels natural, giving the story an emotional foundation that doesn't rely on grand speeches or unnecessary sentimentality.
India Brown also deserves considerable credit as Emmalin. Her storyline explores the struggle for freedom from a very different perspective, and her determination to escape slavery provides some of the film's most compelling moments. A particular highlight is her performance of Wildflower, a beautiful musical sequence that allows Brown to showcase her vocal ability while giving the character an opportunity to express herself beyond the restrictions of her circumstances.
Musically, Drummer Boy is considerably stronger than I expected. Some of the early numbers feel a little clumsy, seemingly more interested in explaining the story than allowing it to develop naturally. However, the quality improves as the film progresses, with the songs becoming more seamlessly integrated into the narrative.
The musical performances are a genuine strength. Lucas Leach arguably steals the vocal show, while the supporting cast provides some terrific singing and dancing. The choreography is particularly enjoyable, with several well-staged numbers that bring energy and personality to the film. There is also an impressive attention to the visual composition of these sequences, suggesting the Smallbones have a genuine appreciation for musical theatre and understand what makes the genre entertaining.
The production values are equally impressive. The opening action sequence establishes the dangers of the period, while the later battle scenes give the historical setting a welcome physical presence. These moments provide a good contrast to the musical numbers and help maintain the film's sense of scale.
Faith is another important element, with themes of forgiveness, compassion, sacrifice and family running throughout. The Christian messages are clear, but they are delivered with warmth rather than feeling overly forceful. The film also draws an interesting parallel between America's struggle for independence and Emmalin's personal fight to escape slavery, exploring the idea that freedom should never be denied to anyone.
There is undoubtedly a sentimental quality to much of the storytelling, and viewers expecting a particularly sophisticated examination of the American Revolution may be disappointed. However, the film's sincerity is one of its greatest strengths. It is a heartfelt production that offers its messages with genuine affection, rather than attempting to force them upon its audience.
At over two hours, Drummer Boy could certainly benefit from a little trimming, particularly around some of its less convincing story developments. Nevertheless, despite my general lack of enthusiasm for musicals, I found myself thoroughly enjoying it. The characters are likeable, the performances are strong, and the music provides plenty of entertainment.
Drummer Boy doesn't get everything right, but it succeeds where it matters most. It is an engaging, uplifting and occasionally moving musical drama, supported by an excellent ensemble and some genuinely memorable songs.
I went into Drummer Boy with fairly modest expectations, but came away having enjoyed it considerably more than anticipated. A little overlong and occasionally simplistic, perhaps, but ultimately a thoroughly enjoyable film that won me over.
I score Drummer Boy a solid 9 out of 10.
In Cinemas Now!
